Off-the-shelf software is made for everyone, which is its strength and its weakness. It’s quick to start and cheap to try, but it fits the average business, and nobody runs an average business. Bespoke software is made for you, but it has a reputation for being expensive and slow. Here’s how to decide which you need, and where.

When off-the-shelf is the right answer

If thousands of businesses do a job in much the same way, someone has already built good software for it. Use it.

  • Accounts and VAT, with something like Xero or QuickBooks
  • Payroll
  • Email, calendars and documents, with Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace
  • Taking card payments and direct debits, with Stripe or GoCardless

Rules decide how these jobs are done, not your way of working. Building your own would cost more and do less. We’d tell you the same.

Signs it’s stopped fitting

Off-the-shelf software starts to cost you when the way you work doesn’t match the way it was designed. You’ll usually notice the workarounds before you notice the problem.

  • A spreadsheet kept alongside it, because the software can’t hold something you need.
  • The same details typed into two or three systems that don’t talk to each other.
  • Paying for several subscriptions that each do a slice of one job.
  • A process that only one person understands, because it lives in their head rather than the software.
  • Your team saying “the system won’t let us” about something that should be simple.

None of these is a disaster on its own. Together, they’re where the hours go.

Side by side

Off-the-shelf

  • Quick to start, often the same day
  • Low monthly cost per user
  • Built for the typical business in your sector
  • You change your process to fit it
  • Joins up with other tools only where someone has built a link

Bespoke

  • Weeks to build rather than minutes to sign up
  • Traditionally a large bill up front
  • Built around the way you actually work
  • It changes to fit you, including as you grow
  • Joins up the tools you already use, so nothing is typed twice

The honest downsides of bespoke

Bespoke software has earned its reputation. Bought the traditional way, you pay £5,000 to £20,000 before you’ve seen anything work, the project often takes months, and once it’s live you depend on whoever built it to keep it running.

We set fifth day up to take those risks off you. You see an interactive prototype and storyboards before anything is built. The build usually takes two to four weeks. There’s nothing to pay up front, and the monthly price, from £199, includes hosting, support and updates. Once the minimum term is up, you can stop with 30 days’ notice.

The usual answer: both

Most of the businesses we work with keep their off-the-shelf tools. The bespoke part goes around them: one app holding the jobs, customers and kit in the shape your business needs, kept in step with your accounting software, your inbox and the rota. The off-the-shelf software keeps doing what it’s good at, and nobody types the same thing twice.

A good starting point is to list the tools you use and draw lines between the ones your team copies information across. Every line is a candidate.